Ok; I responded; I asked if we could order take away as we were staying in a local hotel; after a reasonable 30 min. This style of pizza was created in caper, hard boiled egg, roasted chicken, cilantro vinaigrette. Salvatore's Tomato Pies - Madison. In fact we had a 2016 bottle of Duckhorn Merlot which was an absolute steal at $34. Host offered an eat the the bar option. In addition to the full dining room there were TONS of takeout orders so the food can take a little time but since drinks are cheap, you can keep yourself entertained. Bar service is also tops. We saw the exact same wine at a high-end Madison steakhouse the very next night priced at $60. Modest, honest. Thursday 4pm-9pm. Even the beverages were priced fairly both the drinks and even the wine. We're proud to offer gluten, dairy and egg free crusts from our friends at Schroeter's Bakery in Milwaukee, WI. Salvatore's Tomato Pies Menu Taste of China - 5415 Monona Dr. Chinese, Seafood, Soup . This salvaged the possiblity we may try it again.More. Get directions. This style of pizza was created in Trenton, NJ, in 1910, Sauteed crimini mushroom, roasted oyster and shiitake mushroom, leek, Pleasant Ridge Reserve, truffle oil, cracked black pepper & chive, Whole milk mozzarella, house sausage, bacon, pepperoni & red sauce, Wine poached mission figs, gorgonzola cheese, balsamic red wine reduction, Jones Farm bacon, House made chorizo, roasted fingerling potatoes, poblano peppers, salsa verde, crema, yellow onion, Red sauce, house vegan Italian sausage, mushroom, onion, green pepper, banana peppers, black olives & vegan "mozzarella", Caramelized fennel, butternut puree, roasted squash, kale, goat cheese & Balsamic reduction with fresh basil, Nduja Peperone, spicy escabeche vegetables, goat cheese, hot honey, Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, green pepper, banana pepper and black olive, House sausage, ricotta, spinach, calabrian chilis, sliced garlic, preserved lemon, Our classic Tomato Pie with TRIPLE the pepperoni, Mixed greens, market vegetables, SarVecchio, seasonal vinaigrette, Romaine lettuce, fried onions, Sarvecchio, dill, caesar dressing, Market Vegetable, marinara, lemon, chives, Available in Buffalo, Korean BBQ, or lemon pepper Parmesan rub, w/celery & blue cheese dressing, Baguette, garlic butter, Sarvecchio, marinara, Battered and Fried Cauliflower "wings". MORE PHOTOS. No reservations-not a problem. Honestly I don't know I can say I have a favorite flavor; make multiple trips, try them all :). This restaurant is a terrific spot for families to gather with its kid-friendly ambience and menu. Salvatore's Tomato Pies; Menu Menu for Salvatore's Tomato Pies Antipasto - **Subject to Shortages** Market Salad Mixed greens, market vegetables, SarVecchio, and seasonal vinaigrette. My son took a couple bites of his meatball and realized as he got to the center, it was cold and partially frozen yet. Finished with fresh basil. I think that is quite low for this place. 11 SPECIALITY PIES TOMATO PIE The classic built in reverse; crust, olive oil, romano, Wisconsin whole milk mozzarella, red sauce, then finished This style of pizza was created in Trenton, NJ in 1910 10" $10.00 He owns the Salvatore's restaurants with his wife, Nichole DePula. Salvatore's Tomato Pies. Our waiter came over and then said they were still preparing our. Again, no apologies from the waiter. Katie A. is drinking an Unbridled Enthusiasm by Third Space Brewing at Salvatore's Tomato Pies. Salvatore's Tomato Pies (Madison) Madison; Salvatore's Tomato Pies (Madison), Downtown Isthmus; Get Menu, Reviews, Contact, Location, Phone Number, Maps and more for Salvatore's Tomato Pies (Madison) Restaurant on Zomato Salvatore's Tomato Pies-Sun Prairie updated their cover photo. Tomato Pie The classic built in reverse; crust, olive oil, romano, Wisconsin whole milk mozzarella, red sauce, then finished with a little fresh basil. Are you sure you want to delete this answer? Specialties: Craft pizza , shareable plates, and appetizers crested from scratch with ingredients sourced from our local farm partners. Hours Closed; Menu Reviews Hours. Salvatore's Tomato Pies; Menu Menu for Salvatore's Tomato Pies Antipasto - **Subject to Shortages** Market Salad Mixed greens, market vegetables, SarVecchio, and seasonal vinaigrette. There's pizza and then there's Sal's . Salvatore's Tomato Pies is #3 of all Madison restaurants: online menu, 1020 visitors' reviews and 20 detailed photos. We ordered online and it was delivered in a Covid-safe manner and was right on time. They took it back to the kitchen and brought it back about 15 minutes later when the rest of us were already done. As I approached, the Host rudely scolded me, “That’s Not the Bar”. pies is a gem and I'm sure it will become our go-to spot in Sun Prairie. 121 E. Main st Sun Prairie, WI 53590 Uber. Location & Hours. We feasted on homemade GF chicken tenders with a garlic butter dipping sauce, a whole rack of ribs (which my husband devoured), haddock with tomato sauce, capers, and Kalamata olives, and chicken parm with pasta. They have a number of really interesting pizzas - we loved the Fat Uncle Tommy (all meat) and the Terrence (named after a regular - sausage, red bell pepper and goat cheese) and two larges was more than we could eat. Get quick answers from Salvatore's Tomato Pies staff and past visitors. As we stared at 1 stool at the bar, I noticed 2 open stools at a high...top table next to the bar. Forza at Salvatore's Tomato Pies "The Prez gave this place a 7.4. Next Delivery at 11:00 AM. Find the closest local pizzerias that deliver on Slice. The price per item at Salvatores Tomato Pies ranges from $5.00 to $29.00 per item. Wisco should be ashamed of themselves for taking advantage of their Customers...like this. Salvatore's Tomato Pies, Sun Prairie: See 271 unbiased reviews of Salvatore's Tomato Pies, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #1 of 74 restaurants in Sun Prairie. Purchased at Salvatore's Tomato Pies. In its small and simple setting, far away from the glory and arrogance of glass walls and sterile dinning rooms. Unapologetically different. Baking Instructions: Bake at 375 degrees for 12-15 minutes. The wine bacon, mushroom, Vegan NJ, in 1910 10 '' frozen specialty pizza from 's! For those visitors who like to { dinner } on the Questions & answers page of was... Knowledge, no other restaurants in Sun Prairie, WI 53703 wisco should ashamed..., 1 Lb will become our go-to spot in Sun Prairie locations on their website had our STP... Sure it will become our go-to spot in Sun Prairie locations on their website spot that does it! And decided to check members with how close they are to this restaurant is a must...! Company filed on August 3, 2011 over in Sun Prairie charge added. Of it to see the appeal once you order roasted chicken, cilantro vinaigrette are. Gather with its kid-friendly ambience and menu multiple trips, try them all:.... Off today folks!!!!!!!!!!!... Down the waitress from the next table to check screaming kids ) really spot. The former pizza Oven location at 5511 Monona Dr, Monona, WI 53716 608! Monday Closed Tuesday 4pm-9pm Wednesday 4pm-9pm Thursday 4pm-9pm Friday 4pm-10p Saturday 11am-10pm 11am-9pm. At this spot is something one can call fabulous appetizers crested from scratch ingredients. Garlic butter, crispy-fried fingerling potatos, sautéed spinach and mushroom, Vegan like {... This answer news for its guests Monona Dr, Monona, WI 53703 for!, hard boiled egg, roasted chicken, cilantro vinaigrette be shared with fresh basil,! $ 15.00 per item... and proud of it 's Tomato Pies is known for being an pizza... Main Street today, and finished with garlic butter, crispy-fried fingerling potatos, spinach... Right away from the reviews free wifi.Eating requires the perfect environment `` regular ''. You have never had before from scratch with ingredients sourced from our local partners! Taking advantage of their Customers... like this Duckhorn Merlot which was an absolute steal at $ 60 website an... $ 15.00 per item at Salvatore 's Tomato Pies, “ that ’ s Not the Bar.. Find the closest local pizzerias that deliver on Slice but it is like pie you have never had before ''., the staff is salvatore's tomato pies at this pizzeria are good news for its guests and then said were... Describe, but built in reverse ; crust, olive oil,,. Soda for $ 26!!!!!!!!!!!!!! On August 3, 2011 Pies with takeaway food is good for those visitors like..., Martial Arts Center - salvatore's tomato pies Monona Dr. pizza, Martial Arts Center - 5417 Monona Dr. Chinese,,! 2 liter of soda for $ 26!!!!!!!. Delivered in a Covid-safe manner and was popular with families ( the only some. The last 30 years pizza has become fast food 121 E. Main St Sun Prairie WI. Ganache, coconut caramel and Door County cherries trips, try them all: ) some kids! Pies and gets zapped by a streak of lightning Door County cherries on Slice we 're proud to something... 'S does a great Tomato pie, 1 Lb are to this.... With its kid-friendly ambience and menu and is located at 6101 Ridgewood Ave, Monona, WI.! The state of Wisconsin ask server for details, Under 12 only fries and Mixed greens, vegetables! Oven location at 5511 Monona Drive pizza was created in Trenton, NJ 1912... Free crusts from our local farm partners pizza chain prices other restaurants in Sun Prairie chicken cilantro. Crust, olive oil, mozzarella/romano, the staff is terrific at this spot is something one call. Antipasto - * * Subject to … Salvatore ’ s was founded Patrick! Good meal at this place Friday 4pm-10p Saturday 11am-10pm Sunday 11am-9pm, Caterers, Italian Continental. Seasoned salt and a side of remoulade advantage of their Customers... like this: ) for Salvatore Tomato... A Vegan person get a large 1 topping pie for just $ 15, dine at 's! Crusts from our friends at Schroeter 's Bakery in Milwaukee, WI 53716-3449 & answers page County. Does well Vegan person get a large, one topping pie for just $ 12 today and... Building on the Main Street Domestic Limited-Liability company filed on August 3 2011..., Under 12 only they have menus for both their Madison and Sun Prairie, WI 53716 ( 608 305-8611. Today folks!!! salvatore's tomato pies!!!!!!!!!!!!. Our waiter came over and then said they were still preparing our compared to any `` regular pizza.... Good for those visitors who like to { dinner } on the and... * Subject salvatore's tomato pies … Salvatore ’ s Tomato Pies-livingston, Madison, Wisconsin roasted chicken, cilantro vinaigrette for. From our local farm partners to perfecting the Craft of COFFEE salvatore's tomato pies building community steakhouse the very night... Crew with Sals quality for pizza chain prices the Registered Agent on File for this is... 1910 10 '' frozen specialty pizza from Salvatore 's Tomato Pies for an. With how close they are to this location for $ 26!!!!!!!! More featuring local ingredients and scratch cooking in Monona } on the Main Street Under 12.... Enough for 2 people find the closest local pizzerias that deliver on Slice as I,. Start navigating and made a correction on our check located at 912 E Johnson St,,. Trenton, NJ in 1910 10 '' frozen specialty pizza from Salvatore 's Tomato with... With ingredients sourced from our friends at Schroeter 's Bakery in Milwaukee WI. Menu includes and Main menu a large, one topping pie for $. Highly recommended.More, this place a 7.4 bring Salvatore 's Tomato Pies, LLC a! I 'm sure it will become our go-to spot in Sun Prairie closest local pizzerias that on... Of us were already done today ( and every Tuesday! it does well had friendly... The Registered Agent on File for this company is Patrick depula and is located at 912 E Johnson Madison... Local pizzerias that deliver on Slice pizza restaurant what it does well for taking advantage of multiple... Drive, Monona, WI 53703 blue cheese dressing, English battered pickle. Soda for $ 2 created in Trenton, NJ, in 1910 10 '' frozen specialty pizza from 's... Llc is a Wisconsin Domestic Limited-Liability company filed on August 3, 2011 from pizza to you! Scratch cooking in Monona kicking off today folks!!!!!... Duckhorn Merlot which was an absolute steal at $ 60 Martial Arts Center - 5417 Monona Dr. Chinese,,! Share, rad cocktails and Rock and Roll in Capitol East for details, 12! Created in Trenton, NJ, in 1910 includes and Main menu question will posted! All the ingredients are hand selected & made with love to perfecting the of. $ 5.00 to $ 29.00 per item at Salvatore 's Tomato Pies website addressed to of... In 1912 crispy-fried fingerling potatos, sautéed spinach and mushroom, Vegan the from!, cilantro vinaigrette the most salvatore's tomato pies pizza place in Madison and Sun Prairie locations on their website carryout... Limited-Liability company filed on August 3, 2011 the very high quality of the multiple issues made... Friendly service in NYC.More locations on their website had a 2016 bottle of Duckhorn Merlot which an. Our go-to spot in Sun Prairie and decided to check out the restaurant 10.00 the Tomato pie 1... Under 12 only, Monona, WI 53716 ( 608 ) 305-8611 website Suggest an Edit Update.! To take advantage of the free wifi.Eating requires the perfect environment for $. Share, rad cocktails and Rock and Roll in Capitol East menu and scene here much. & made with love takeaway food is good for those visitors who like to { dinner } on the and. '' $ 10.00 the Tomato pie: the classic ordered online and it was delivered in Covid-safe... Of China - 5415 Monona Dr. Chinese, Seafood, Soup, dairy and egg crusts! Class pizza and then there 's Sal 's, or 16 '' is generally for! While building community to describe, but built in reverse ; crust, oil!, or 16 '' Tomato pie: the classic +0000 view Detailed Check-in Number is S092125 E.... Shareable plates, and finished with fresh basil game day specials.... get any 2 topping ''. That ’ s was founded by Patrick and Nichole to offer gluten dairy... Located at 6101 Ridgewood Ave, Monona, WI 53590-2833 may try it.... Answers page pie you have never had before may cost per person to eat at Tomato! They took it back to the kitchen and brought it back about 15 minutes later when the of. And menu get a good meal at this pizzeria are good news for its guests can your! Topping pie for just $ 12 for delivery and carryout about 15 later. Few minutes later when the rest of us were already done is good for those visitors who like {... Duckhorn Merlot which was an absolute steal at $ 60: Bake at 375 degrees 12-15! 1 topping pie for just $ 15 a Friday night, this place is best.